Josh Naylor’s situation with the Cleveland Guardians is precarious as he heads into his final season of team control, projected to earn $12 million in arbitration following a strong season with 31 homers and 108 RBI. Historically, the Guardians typically avoid long-term contracts for players nearing free agency, and Naylor’s lack of an extension suggests he may be traded this offseason. Though he showed impressive metrics, a decline in performance is a concern, and his future is clouded by the Guardians’ financial uncertainties, particularly after losing significant broadcasting revenue. Trade interest exists, especially from teams like the Mariners and Pirates, who seek first base options. The Guardians must navigate these dynamics carefully, as moving Naylor could leave a void in their lineup, especially if they cannot compensate with immediate offensive reinforcements.
- Naylor hit a career-best 31 home runs and had 108 RBIs in 2024.
- His projected arbitration salary for 2025 is $12 million, up from $6.5 million in 2024.
Yes, But
While trading Naylor is a possibility, the Guardians may retain him if they can accommodate a higher payroll or find an attractive trade offer. Additionally, the team’s offensive needs could prompt them to seek alternatives rather than parting ways with a key player.
State of Play
- Cleveland has experienced fluctuating attendance and broadcasting revenue challenges.
- Several teams are actively seeking first base help, aligning with Naylor’s trade potential.
Expect the Guardians to weigh trade options for Naylor carefully. If they proceed with a trade, they may look for immediate MLB-ready players and prospects, while also addressing their need for offensive talent…