Additional Coverage:
- CNN defamation trial: Losing case expected but still a bad bruise for the network, insider says (foxnews.com)
CNN Employee Comments on Defamation Case
In the aftermath of CNN’s recent high-profile defamation case, an employee has acknowledged the negative impact on the network’s reputation. The employee emphasized that losing such a case is detrimental and has left a mark on the organization.
Case Details
The case involved Navy veteran Zachary Young, who alleged that CNN smeared him by implying he profited illegally from helping people flee Afghanistan. The jury awarded Young $5 million in damages and found punitive damages were warranted. However, CNN and Young reached a settlement before the punitive damages were determined.
Internal Messages
During the trial, internal CNN messages were revealed that showed hostility towards Young. One message called him a “s–tbag,” while another said he had a “punchable face.” A CNN correspondent also expressed a desire to “nail” Young and referred to him as “your funeral bucko.”
CNN’s Response
CNN has stated that it will learn from the case and remains committed to strong reporting. However, an employee believes the issues in this story are not a reflection of the company’s culture.
Impact on Morale
The employee noted that morale at CNN is currently low due to declining ratings and reports of pending layoffs. The defamation case has not led to any internal rallying behind the network.
Expert Analysis
Erik Wemple of The Washington Post criticized CNN’s journalists for their poor performance on the witness stand, which has amplified the impact of the case. A former CNN employee condemned the network for its lack of basic journalistic functions and arrogance.
Young’s Hopes
Despite the outcome, Young expressed no animosity towards CNN. He hopes the network and other media organizations will use this experience to improve their practices and avoid similar mistakes in the future.